Go to Google Groups Home    sci.bio.evolution
Re: Genetic advantage in interracial mating.

Tim Tyler <seemy...@cyberspace.org>

RAGLANDMYC...@AOL.COM wrote:
> Tim Tyler wrote:
>> The usual rule in biology is to choose a mate who is like you,
>> but not /too/ much like you.

>> Dangers of too much inbreeding include the problems you mentioned.

>> Dangers of too much outbreeding include half breeds, mule effects
>> and incompatible gene complexes - effects which have most likely
>> contributed to the stigma historically associated with such
>> unions - e.g. see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miscegenation

> I doubt you would have stated this without researching it first. As far
> as human engaging in interracial mating I think everyone is aware of
> the term "half-breed". I'm also aware at times throughout history
> "half-breeds" have had a hard social time being accepted and fitting
> in. I'm not aware of human "half-breeds" having mule like effects and
> incompatible gene complexes. Can you provide evidence of signifigant
> mule effects and incompatible gene complexes among humans who
> interracially mate? In short, evidence biological abnormalities are
> more prevalent in this special population than the average population.

An example of the other side of the coin to hybrid vigor
in humans:

``And there is a downside to intermarriage.

   The obverse of hybrid vigor: the possibility that combining
   genes which didn't evolve to work together might cause
   health problems due to incompatibilities.

   For example, ace genetics reporter Nicholas Wade wrote in
   the New York Times ( 11/11/05) about a gene variant that is
   benign in whites and Asians but more than triples the heart
   attack risk in part-white African-Americans:

     "Dr. Stefansson [of Iceland's DeCode Genetics] said he
      believed that the more active version of this gene might
      have risen to prominence in Europeans and Asians because
      it conferred extra protection against infectious
      disease.

     "Along with the protection would have come a higher risk
      of heart attack because plaques that build up in the
      walls of the arteries could become inflamed and rupture.
      But because the active version of the gene started to be
      favored long ago, Europeans and Asians have had time to
      develop genetic changes that offset the extra risk of
      heart attack.

     "The active version of the inflammatory gene would have
      passed from Europeans into African-Americans only a few
      generations ago, too short a time for development of
      genes that protect against heart attack, Dr. Stefansson
      suggested."

      [Genetic Find Stirs Debate on Race-Based Medicine]

   Like hybrid vigor, genetic incompatibilities across racial
   lines unquestionably exist in some cases. So the key
   empirical question is: what the net balance of the two
   opposing forces?''

  - http://www.vdare.com/sailer/060904_interracial.htm

My guess is that one of the parental fears behind the
common disapproval of interracial marriages, is the
concern that any offspring will not fit well into
either family's social group - due to not being
perceived as being a full relative as a result
of differing racial markers.
--
__________
  |im |yler  http://timtyler.org/  t...@tt1lock.org  Remove lock to reply.